Bob lives in Idaho, and reads my column in his local paper. Bob wrote: “I really enjoy your columns. Your practical knowledge and no-nonsense approach reminds me of my father-in-law, who was an architect and builder.” Bob mentioned that he was also an amateur radio operator like me. It’s loads of fun to hear from readers with similar interests!
Bob asked for my advice on how to replace his cupped and cracked 12-inch-wide wood fascia boards with a more durable material. One of the deal breakers was that he wanted to paint the replacement material to match the dark-green color of his existing trim.
Three different methods of solving this problem come to mind. The least expensive way is to paint the existing fascia boards, assuming they’re still in fair shape. Bob did send two photos, and the boards have seen better days. There are quite a few exterior spackling compounds and epoxy wood fillers that do a magnificent job of filling large cracks and holes. These materials can be sanded, and they all accept paint. Cupped boards can sometimes be made flat using stainless steel screws.
You may have had bad luck with paint in the past. Believe me, I understand that frustration, but exterior house paint can last 25 years, if you apply it according to the simple instructions on the label. I painted the redwood siding on my own home in 1997, and it still looks as good today as the day I painted it.
The resin component of the paint is urethane. Understand that paint at its most basic level is nothing more than colored glue. You want to use a paint that is ultra-sticky, and urethane fits the bill. Visit a traditional national-brand paint store and you’ll discover that urethane exterior house paints can be purchased in any color and different sheens.
A second solution is to wrap the fascia boards with painted aluminum coil stock. Aluminum holds paint exceedingly well, and some coil stock comes from the factory painted a dark green color.
You can rent a metal-bending brake from a tool rental business. These simple machines allow you to make precision bends so the aluminum conforms to the shape of the fascia boards. There are numerous videos on YouTube that show you exactly how to use a brake. It’s never been easier to discover how to do something. You can also watch other videos showing you how to install coil stock over fascia boards.
The most expensive and time-consuming solution is to remove the fascia boards and replace them with a non-wood material. Fiber cement is an option. I have fiber cement siding on my home and on a shed I built. You can paint it any color you prefer. While it has wood fibers in it, the cement prevents the boards from cracking, cupping or rotting like ordinary wood.
You could also use a plastic fascia board. There are several brands. The only drawback with plastic is that it has a very high expansion/contraction coefficient. The manufacturers caution that painting the material with dark colors can lead to catastrophic paint failure as the plastic material expands beyond the limits of the paint.
I have tested this material on my own home with great success. I had to replace my front door several years ago and used plastic trim instead of wood. This door faces south and doesn’t have any protection from the sunlight. It’s painted a fairly dark green, and after 6 years, the paint has not peeled. I did use the urethane paint, and I feel its stickiness is the reason the paint continues to bond to the plastic.
You can often avoid the expensive process of replacing wood trim by simply protecting it from the ravages of water. Water and wood trim don’t play well together. If your wood trim, siding, fencing and railings are in great shape, think about taking the time to do what I did with my house all those years ago. Get a good quality urethane paint, read the label and apply it exactly as directed. You may never have to paint it again!
Tim Carter has worked as a home improvement professional for more than 30 years. To submit a question or to learn more, visit AsktheBuilder.com.